Table of Contents

Listen On: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Google Podcasts | YouTube

Rennie Intelligence is known for compiling the latest demographic, economic and development data and translating it into actionable knowledge for their clients – which just so happen to be Western Canada’s largest developers, REITs & policy makers.

This week, Ryan Berlin, Director of Intelligence and Senior Economist, and Andrew Ramlo, Vice President of Advisory Services, sit down with Matt & Adam to chart the market from bird’s eye view down to granular. And, trust us – the market takeaways are next level! Will the Spring spring? Will the Fall fall? and everything in between and beyond. This will set you up for the rest of 2023. Actionable intelligence!

Guest Information

Andrew Ramlo

Andrew Ramlo is the Vice President of Intelligence at rennie group. He is passionate about bringing intelligent analysis to whatever he does. At rennie, he is able to bring that enthusiasm for data and analysis to bear on questions about their ever evolving real estate market. Given how important our homes are in our day to day lives, stories about them are often driven by emotion rather than rational analysis. He likes to be able to dig down into those stories to find the data-based insights to help people to understand the trends in our real estate markets.

Ryan Berlin

Ryan Berlin is the Senior Economist at rennie (rennie Intelligence Division). He sees the relationship between the company and himself as being mutually beneficial. He has been able to bring a certain base of knowledge and ability into a space (rennie intelligence) where there was a pre-identified need, and on the flip side he feels supported in what he does at rennie. He considers himself fortunate to be in a position where he feels like what he’s doing matters.

Episode Summary

How will interest rates, immigration and an aging population impact the Vancouver real estate market? Rennie’s Andrew Ramlo and Ryan Berlin sit down to share the data with us and provide an overview of the Vancouver real estate spring market!

Before we jump into today’s interview, let’s hear from Ray Macklem at Nest Mortgage about Silicon Valley Bank and the recent lending landscape changes:

Ray: The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank has changed the market outlook for interest rates. We’re now sending markets into a position where we’re likely to see a few rate cuts by the Bank of Canada by July and even a third cut by the end of the year.

With the US Fed, we’re expecting they’ll either keep rates steady or even cut them minorly. Either way, they won’t be as severe as they had said they’d be before the collapse.

These banks, Silicon Valley and Signature, going under has exposed some of the effects of the interest rate increases that haven’t been focused on. Central banks were mostly focused on inflation but this is changing the narrative.

At the start of the year, we expected the Bank of Canada to cut rates by the end of 2023. In February, we thought we’d see one more increase by July. And now in March, we’ve gone in the other direction. Central bankers are having to pause and evaluate how much these rate increases are affecting things.

Should you go fixed or variable? You can expect downward pressure on fixed rates, which we’re already seeing. For variable rates, people are expecting them to come down a bit more quickly and are braving the wave. Based on our research, variable rates typically come out ahead. It is a decision based on your individual risk tolerance but an argument can certainly be made for going variable.

We live in an age where information is so accessible and that can lend itself to overreactions. The truth likely lies somewhere in the middle. What’s happening today is likely to change.

You can find me at ​​https://www.nestmortgage.co/contact/raymacklem,  https://www.instagram.com/rayatnestmortgage/ or email me at [email protected].

Who is Andrew Ramlo?

I have a background in urban and economic geography and a Masters in planning. I’ve been dabbling in real estate for the last 20 years. With Rennie in advisory services, we work for the municipalities, developers and some of the ministries. It’s a wide and diverse runway. We also cover a broad range of issues.

Ryan and I have been working together for 20 years, moved over to Rennie about eight years ago and established the intelligence team. After covid, we hived off advisory services, which I run. Ryan handles the intelligence team.

Who is Ryan Berlin?

As Andy said, we’ve been working together for a few decades now. I head up the intelligence function at Rennie. We have a team with diverse skill sets so we can procure and synthesize data for whoever our audience is. We provide information for realtors, developers, government and the general public as well.

How is the housing market?

Every point in the market is unique. But what makes this point particularly interesting is that it’s all about inflation. It impacts interest rates which impacts the housing market in terms of affordability and the number of transactions.

Right now, buyers can’t afford what they want and sellers can’t get what they want for their homes. So it’s a very sticky market with not a lot of movement.

More broadly, inflation and interest rates also affect housing stock. Developers have had to press pause on projects, particularly rental projects, because proformas just don’t make sense anymore. We’ve also seen significant increases in rent, but not to the degree that it offsets new lending rates.

It’s not a complete halt but there is a grind down. In the resale market, we’ve been below 3000 transactions per month in Metro Vancouver for the last eight months, which we haven’t seen in the last decade.

Everyone is waiting for the other shoe to drop; the uncertainty is paralyzing. We’re sensing that the rate hikes are coming to an end and we’ll see more stability, but no one knows for sure. Some people are being enticed to come back into the market but we’re not at 2019 levels by any stretch.

How does the spring real estate market play out?

We track the market on a daily basis and right now inventory is remarkably flat. Typically we see a 30% rise in the first quarter but this year it’s only a third of that. This is usually the most active period of the year but we’re not seeing it.

People are not listing their home if they don’t have to. We have a strong labour market and people have a lot of savings. For the majority of homeowners, they can afford their home.

I predict we’ll see more listings going forward with these high interest rates. Sales are tracking higher than the sub 3000 trend of the last eight months.

What will it take to impact housing inventory?

Good news in the economy won’t be enough to motivate sellers to put their homes on the market. We need to watch the variable rate mortgage market because it’s in rough shape.

CIBC just published a reportshowing $52 billion of $72 billion variable rate mortgages are interest only payments with negative amortization. That’s a rough situation to be in! When those homeowners renew, their payments are going to go through the roof and they haven’t paid down their principal.

I think that increase will impact homeowners and we will see some new listings. We’ll see a little bit of that but I don’t think it will define the market.

Had inventory been at normal levels, would housing prices have dropped off?

That’s an interesting question. I think one thing that is defining the sticky market we’re in now is a lack of options for buyers. So there is pent up demand.

A third of all listings have been on the market for 60 days; last year it was half that time. There’s a large segment of existing inventory that is just not moving. Buyers don’t feel that they have options. Once options open up and buyers come out of the woodwork, prices may start to rebound.

We also have to remember that the population in the region and province is still growing. People need to live somewhere. We’re seeing a significant rise in rents and some of that is likely due to lack of buying opportunity. People who want to buy are landing in the rental market because there aren’t enough options. The sub 1% vacancy rate on rentals is also pushing rental rates up.

What other factors, besides inventory and interest rates, are affecting the real estate market?

There are always a lot of factors impacting the real estate market but what’s driving the market right now is the relationship between inflation, interest rates and pricing, with inventory on the margin. If interest rates went back to 2.5%, the market would be super active.

It’s also about the people. We upped our immigration target to 500,000 people coming into the country in the next two years. We need to accommodate more people across the country. So it’s not just the economy, but the people too.

Let’s talk about Canada’s immigration trends.

Starting in 2017, the federal government upped their immigration target from 250,000 people per year to 310,000 then 340,000 then 450,000 and finally 500,000 by 2025. That’s double our historic norm and puts us at the top of all G20 countries with a 1.4% immigration rate.

The objectives are to address our aging population and targets bringing in younger people, who will impact the labour force. An unintended consequence of addressing our demographic problem is the impact of immigration on our housing challenges. Within the next 5-7 years, I think housing markets in Canada are going to be significantly challenged.

Will we see a increase in demand for rental stock due to immigration?

Absolutely, especially in the short term. Immigrants and migrants tend to land in the rental market when they first arrive; about 80% of them do. But once people are established, there is a transition to owning.

How many immigrants are expected to settle in the Lower Mainland?

One thing to note is that those immigration targets are for permanent residents, some of whom already reside in the country. Historically, 70% were new and 30% were already here. But in the last couple of years, that ratio has flipped.

However, that’s being offset by the huge targets. In the last year, a record 1.2 million permits were issued; the previous high was 800,000 or 900,000.

Our largest metropolitan areas will be most directly affected by immigration. Metro Vancouver receives double the international in-flow than the general population. That also has impacts for domestic movers, such as those who leave the Lower Mainland for more affordability or availability. So it’s a cascading effect.

How does this all play out?

People will be less likely to choose the Lower Mainland as things become more and more expensive. That will affect the secondary markets, like Kelowna and Victoria. It’s going to be a very challenging time for the housing markets.

How the housing market is really depends on who you are. For developers, sure they have to press pause right now. But in the long term, it’ll be a strong market to sell or rent out product. But if you’re trying to get into the market? It’s going to be super challenging.

On the supply side, we finished 22,000 homes net-new last year. That was down from 25,000 the year before. Looking at our models, we need to add 35,000 net-new homes annually over the next few years. And we’ve never hit that number.

We’ve had lots of conversations with David Eby and that is driving some of the housing changes at the provincial level. He looks at the data too and knows this could be a scary situation.

What’s the breaking point for Vancouver?

We used to talk about “brain drain” – the idea that doctors and highly skilled people were leaving Canada for the US. And we may see that again on a regional level. With the popularity of remote work, people may go to the lowest cost place to live, even if their employer is on the other side of the country. Not everyone can but a segment of people can and are doing this.

For the first time since 2015, BC lost people to Alberta on a net-basis. Alberta gained 19,000 people on a net-basis from across Canada. That’s the largest net in-flow for them in over 40 years.

In this state, people have to make uncomfortable decisions. They will have to move out of neighbourhoods where they’ve lived their whole lives. It’s an uncertain future. But it all can’t work in the way it has been; something has to give.

Is now a good time to buy?

It depends what kind of a buyer you are. If you can afford carrying a variable rate mortgage for a few years, you can ride that down and be in a better position. But not everyone is okay with that.

If you’re a cash buyer, detached homes are down 20% so you could buy for a discount without the higher financing costs. So there’s an opportunity there. For investors, the secondary rental market is very important. People poo-poo the investor who is out to make a profit but it is an important source of rental supply.

For first time buyers who aren’t able to get help from family, they’re stuck. Their max purchase price has gone down.

There’s a huge disconnect between what buyers can afford and what sellers are willing to accept. Unless sellers have a reason for being more flexible with what they will accept, likely due to rising mortgage costs, it will continue to be ships passing in the night.

Are we seeing a lot of reverse mortgages and a generational wealth transfer?

Reverse mortgages are very interesting. Benjamin Tal at the CIBC looked at their mortgage portfolio and found 30% of first time buyers get help from mom and dad to the average tune of $90,000 across Canada. But in the Lower Mainland, that number is $320,000. 10% of move up buyers also get help from mom and dad.

I believe they said under 3% of the funds transferred were from debt – the rest was being transferred from savings. So it’s not reverse mortgages that are driving the transfer of equity.

In Metro Vancouver, two out of every five homeowners is mortgage free.

That number of mortgage-free homeowners is demographically influenced; many are Baby Boomers who paid down their mortgage years ago. But the value of mortgage-free equity in this region is $400 billion; $100 billion of that is with people 75 years and older.

Over the past 10 years, people in the 75+ group released $400 million of equity into the market every month. That could be through a reverse mortgage, people passing away, people moving, etc. We know that number will continue to go up over time based on demography.

Are there similar trends happening in Ontario?

We’re seeing a very similar thing in Toronto. There’s a similar demography in Toronto and it’s the same trend, but on a bigger scale because of their market size.

We’ve always heard talk of blood in the streets. Will the Vancouver market crash?

There’s been talk of a crash in the Vancouver market since 1911. 15 years ago we were talking about the bubble in Vancouver. And we have seen declines, but it hasn’t increased affordability when combined with the increase in interest rates.

Where will the bottom fall out of a market? It’s where there isn’t job growth and population growth. That’s a market that is at risk of long term decline.

But if you have continued job growth, income growth and population growth, you’ll see oscillations around a long term upward trend. I can’t see prices in Vancouver falling to those of Regina or Moncton.

How do our demographics impact the housing market?

Like we saw in the post WWII boom where people created homes of their own, we’ll see that again in the next few years with 25-34 year olds forming households driven by migration and immigration.

We wrote a report 15 years ago called A Perfect Storm, looking at our aging population and declining labour market. The conclusion was we would need to increase our immigration targets. In 2017, the federal government dusted our report off and started doing just that.

If we turn off migration in our models, we continue to generate increasing net-new demand for housing for about 15 years. That’s fascinating! We always attribute the need for new housing to us adding people, which is true. But we’re also having children who need to move out while the older population is still in their homes, so there’s local demand too.

Life expectancy is increasing and the gap between male and female life expectancy is decreasing. So if an elderly couple can stay together, they’re more likely to stay in their home. It’s usually after the death of a spouse that we’ll see a lifestyle change and home sale.

Economist David Foot predicted that in the 2000s and 2010s we’d see the Boomers aging out of the housing market and into retirement homes. But he didn’t look at the data on people moving.

Every year after 35, your likelihood to move declines. There’s a huge likelihood that people will stay in their homes and covid definitely pushed people in that direction. If you look at the healthcare system, they are also pushing to have services on the community level because they don’t have the capacity to serve the aging population on the healthcare side.

What’s the headline for the rest of 2023?

Ryan: The headline for the rest of 2023 will be, “What’s the fate of interest rates?” It’s interesting as data-geeks who have always been interested in these numbers that now everyone is interested. People know these numbers matter to their world. Interest rates will be the thing that primarily impacts the market in the short term.

Andrew: I agree. The headline will be, “Inflation falls back into the Bank of Canada’s target range.” We’re predicting by April/May/June we’ll be back at target inflation. That’s what the inertia of the math says will happen.

Ryan: We call it the Math Path for Inflation. The Bank of Canada expects the rate of inflation to fall to 3% by summer. We looked at the month-to-month inflationary pressures from last year and expect the pressures from the second half of 2022 to have a bigger impact on 2023.

When we talk about inflation falling, we’re not talking about things becoming cheaper. We’re talking about the rate at which they increase slowing down.

We’re seeing price pressures abate. If they continue to evolve as they did in late 2022, the inertia will push the rate of inflation to 2% by May. If it’s not there, other factors have influenced inflation. But anything could happen!

Some people think there’s no cost to high interest rates. They say we need to crush inflation and should continue raising rates. But there is a real cost and living can become unaffordable.

The current central bank target rate is above what they consider neutral and we still won’t see the full impact for another year. There is a risk to overshooting – people could lose their jobs or their homes. I think the Bank of Canada is going to be looking for reasons to bring the rate back to a neutral place.

Episode Host

Adam Scalena

[email protected]

778-866-4574

Adam is a full-service realtor, specializing in Vancouver’s best areas. His systematic approach to real estate and dedication to his clients has consistently placed him within the top 10% of realtors operating within Greater Vancouver.

Matt Scalena

[email protected]

778-847-2854

Matt is real estate obsessed and considers himself a lifelong student of the Vancouver real estate market. As a co-manager of the Scalena Real Estate team, Matt prides himself on expertly advising buyers and sellers on all aspects of the fast-paced, dynamic Vancouver real estate market. He is present at every stage of the process, from that first phone call or email right through to when keys are exchanged between sellers and buyers.

Resources From Episode

Sponsors