Table of Contents

Episode Summary

Listen On: Apple Podcast | Spotify

Something feels off about Canada’s economy, even if the headlines won’t say it. Moody’s Analytics economist Brendan LaCerda sits down with Adam & Matt to cut through the noise and explain why the country is stuck in a state of economic limbo, with growth grinding to a halt while businesses freeze in place. From the looming USMCA renegotiation to the surprising downside of high oil prices, Brendan offers an outsider’s data-driven perspective on where Canada is really headed and what it means for Vancouver real estate. Why is a US economist so concerned about what’s happening up north? Could AI quietly reshape the Canadian economy faster than anyone expects? And is Vancouver’s next housing boom realistically off the table? Don’t miss this essential check-in on the Canadian economy.

Brendan LaCerda

Brendan LaCerda is an associate director and senior economist with Moody’s Analytics. Brendan serves as the lead analyst for the Canadian economic forecast. His primary responsibilities also include the development and improvement of country forecast models. His research is primarily focused on international macroeconomics, healthcare and fiscal policy. Before joining Moody’s Analytics, Brendan worked as a senior economist with IHS Global Insight’s U.S. Macroeconomic Service. Brendan received his PhD in economics from the University of Virginia. He pursued his undergraduate education at the London School of Economics and the University of Notre Dame, where he graduated with a BA in economics and mathematics.

Vancouver Mortgage Rates Are Already Normal: What 2025 Buyers Must Know

Here’s something most Vancouver buyers don’t want to hear. The mortgage rate relief they’ve been waiting for — the thing keeping them on the sidelines — probably isn’t coming. Not in the way they’re imagining, anyway.

Brendan LaCerda, Director of Economic Research at Moody’s Analytics, put it plainly: where mortgage rates sit right now is pretty close to their long-run average. Their long-run equilibrium. That’s not a temporary high on the way back down. That’s normal. And for a market like Vancouver, where affordability was already stretched before rates climbed, that changes the calculus for buyers and sellers alike in a pretty fundamental way.

This isn’t doom and gloom. It’s actually a clarifying insight. Because once you stop waiting for something that isn’t coming, you can start making decisions based on what’s actually in front of you.

What You’ll Learn:

  • Why Moody’s believes current mortgage rates reflect long-run equilibrium, not a temporary spike
  • The one scenario where rates drop dramatically — and why you don’t want it to happen
  • How Canada’s economy has shifted away from the commodity-driven model most people still picture
  • Why Vancouver’s affordability problem is now working against its own demand
  • What Moody’s base case says about Canadian housing through the end of 2026
  • The asymmetric risk picture for Vancouver: small upside, significant downside
  • Why immigration policy changes are making labor market data harder to read

The Only Way Rates Crash Back to 2% Is a Bad Recession

Let’s start with the uncomfortable math.

A lot of buyers are still mentally anchored to pandemic-era mortgage rates. Two percent. Two and a half. The idea that if they just wait long enough, rates will drift back down and suddenly everything becomes affordable again.

LaCerda doesn’t buy it. “People expecting we’re going to go back to the glory days of, I can get a mortgage for like 2 percent — I don’t see that realistically,” he said, “unless there’s some horrible recession where the Bank of Canada just starts slashing rates. That’s the only way we get back to a 2 percent mortgage again.”

Read that twice. The path back to ultra-low rates runs straight through economic catastrophe. That’s not a trade most people would actually want to make.

And the Bank of Canada raising rates from here? LaCerda doesn’t see that either. Not with tariffs creating drag, the labor market softening, and the broader Canadian economy in what he describes as a kind of stasis — not growing, not collapsing, just hanging there.

“The trouble is, if you’re in the real estate market, you shouldn’t anticipate any interest rate relief coming down the road. Where mortgage rates are right now, we think it’s pretty close to their long-run average, their long-run equilibrium.” — Brendan LaCerda, Director, Economic Research, Moody’s Analytics

Canada Is Stuck. Here’s Why.

The bigger picture matters here, because Vancouver doesn’t exist in a vacuum.

LaCerda describes the Canadian economy right now in one word: stasis. Growth has slowed to zero. Not a recession — none of the warning lights are flashing. But not growth either. Businesses are frozen by uncertainty: tariff policy, the USMCA renewal, the US-Iran conflict and what it means for energy markets and global supply chains.

So they’re not hiring aggressively. Not cutting aggressively either. Just waiting.

The base case from Moody’s is that Canada muddles through the first half of 2025, then starts seeing some green shoots emerge toward the end of 2026. That forecast assumes the USMCA negotiations — officially kicking off in July — produce some kind of deal. Tariffs don’t disappear entirely, but they come down enough that businesses can start planning again. It also assumes the geopolitical situation in the Middle East doesn’t escalate further.

Optimistic? Maybe. But LaCerda’s framing is useful: it’s not that the path forward is great, it’s that it becomes clearer. And clearer is enough to restart hiring and investment.

“As long as they’re reduced, and as long as policy isn’t constantly changing, then businesses can get back to planning, and hiring picks back up, investment starts to pick back up.” — Brendan LaCerda, Director, Economic Research, Moody’s Analytics

Vancouver’s Affordability Trap Is Self-Reinforcing Now

Here’s where it gets interesting for Vancouver specifically.

LaCerda made a point that cuts right to the heart of what makes this market different from the rest of Canada. Affordability isn’t just a hardship for buyers — it’s starting to act as a brake on demand itself. The worse it gets, the fewer people decide they can realistically move here. And that works against the price appreciation that Vancouver has historically relied on.

Back-to-back booms in 2016-17 and again around 2020-21. Can you really expect a third? “That just seems unrealistic,” he said.

His framing for the Vancouver risk profile is worth sitting with: small upside, big downside. Even in an optimistic scenario, appreciation is likely to lag the national average. In a negative scenario — prolonged geopolitical conflict, equity correction, labor market softness — the downside is meaningful. Because when valuations are already this high, there’s a lot of room to fall and not much headroom to climb.

The immigration policy shift makes this more complicated too. Changes in immigration are causing the Canadian labor force to actually shrink, which is skewing unemployment numbers lower than the real picture. “I think that probably overstates the health of the labor market,” LaCerda said. For a housing market that needs steady income growth and population growth to sustain demand, that’s not a small caveat.

The Green Shoots Are Real. Just Not Here Yet.

None of this means the market is heading off a cliff. LaCerda pointed to something that actually surprised him: construction activity has stayed remarkably resilient despite everything.

Units under construction in Vancouver — still near all-time record highs when he checked the data before the interview. Pace of new housing starts — slowed slightly, but still brisk. Permitting — still pretty strong. Builders aren’t spooked.

And the demand is out there. People complaining about affordability are people who want to buy a house. That latent demand doesn’t disappear — it just waits for affordability to improve enough to activate it. LaCerda’s house price forecast has prices coming down a little more through 2026, while income growth continues and rates hold steady. That combination slowly improves affordability. Slowly.

“When you do hear people complain about affordability in the housing market, that also means a person who’s complaining about affordability is a person who wants to buy a house. So the demand is out there.” — Brendan LaCerda, Director, Economic Research, Moody’s Analytics

Modest. Gradual. Not the story of another 20 percent annual run. More like a market catching its breath after two back-to-back booms. Which, honestly, might be exactly what it needs.

Episode Host

Adam Scalena

[email protected]

778-866-4574

Adam is a full-service realtor, specializing in Vancouver’s best areas. His systematic approach to real estate and dedication to his clients has consistently placed him within the top 10% of realtors operating within Greater Vancouver.

Matt Scalena

[email protected]

778-847-2854

Matt is real estate obsessed and considers himself a lifelong student of the Vancouver real estate market. As a co-manager of the Scalena Real Estate team, Matt prides himself on expertly advising buyers and sellers on all aspects of the fast-paced, dynamic Vancouver real estate market. He is present at every stage of the process, from that first phone call or email right through to when keys are exchanged between sellers and buyers.

Sponsors

Full Podcast Transcript – Interview with Brendan LaCerda

This transcript has been lightly edited for clarity and readability.

Adam Scalena: We’re here with Brendan LaCerda. He is a director in the economic research group at Moody’s Analytics. Welcome back, Brendan, past guest and favorite. So happy to have you here.

Brendan LaCerda: Adam and Matt, thank you so much for having me. I really appreciate it.

Matt Scalena: Right on. It’s been about a year, I think, since you were last on, Brendan. Can you start by telling our listeners a little bit about yourself?

Brendan LaCerda: Yeah, absolutely. I’m a professional economist. I’ve been with Moody’s for, I’m just about to hit the 10 year mark here. What we do is macroeconomic forecasting. That is predicting the future for all those key macroeconomic variables that banks, insurers, and industry care about. GDP, unemployment, CPI, house prices, interest rates. There’s a long list of all of them, but the idea is we’re going to forecast that, and businesses can utilize that information for planning, risk analysis, things of that sort.

Primarily what we do is alternative macroeconomic scenario forecasting. There are a lot of baseline forecasts out there. Every bank has a baseline forecast. But really where we specialize is in the what if scenarios. The hypothetical of what could happen, and understanding that distribution of risk, and what are the implications of those different risks for your business, or maybe the survivability of your business in a potentially downside economic scenario.

Adam Scalena: Okay, well, one of the reasons we brought you on is because obviously we’ve been looking at the Canadian economy here, and quite a bit has changed since we spoke to you last. We’re in BC, so our economy, I feel like we’re in a bit of an echo chamber, and it’s hard to see what’s going on in our economy as an outsider. You watch from Philadelphia. What are Canadians missing about their own economy?

Brendan LaCerda: Well, you get to see it up close. I see the economy mostly through the data, so maybe that makes me a little less biased since I just have to rely mostly on the numbers. I was trying to think earlier today, how would I sum up Canada’s recent economic performance in one word? It kind of feels like limbo, or stasis, or stalled.

The last time we spoke, tariffs were getting underway. We were pretty concerned about a recession in Canada given the threats that were being made. As it turns out, President Trump didn’t fully follow through on those threats, so the economic fallout ended up being less than we had initially feared. But it was still substantial. What you see in the Canadian data is basically the speed of growth in Canada just slows to zero. So it’s not in a recession. We don’t see any of the key measures flashing big warning lights, trouble, trouble. But the economy’s not really growing.

That reflects a lot of uncertainty among businesses about where tariff policy is headed, what’s going to happen to the USMCA, how this military conflict in the Middle East is going to play out. There’s just so much uncertainty hanging over businesses that they don’t want to embark on big new investments. They don’t want to go on a big hiring spree. They’re playing it conservative. That also means that they’re not laying people off wholesale. They’re not panicked that the sky is falling and we need to clamp down, conserve cash, go into defense mode, citadel mode or something like that. So that’s why I said this stasis, this limbo. You feel the economy just hanging and waiting for something to happen, telling businesses, which way should I go on my payroll or my capital expenditures?

Matt Scalena: Brendan, you listed a bunch of uncertainties there, a lot of them external to Canada. At the very least, I feel like a lot of those we don’t have a lot of control over. This might be outside of your wheelhouse, but how do we get out of this? If uncertainty is the shroud that hangs over new investment and hiring, what’s the game plan?

Brendan LaCerda: These are the same conversations that the prime minister is asking his cabinet. How do we get out of this situation? How can we give businesses more confidence? I don’t think I have a great answer for that because all these issues are just beyond Canada’s control. I don’t think Canada has much influence over US foreign policy, so it’s not clear how it would at all be able to affect what’s going on in Iran.

I think the one big opportunity to resolve the uncertainty is on the tariff front and with trade. We have the official start of the USMCA renewal negotiations kicking off in July. They’re already having behind the scenes talks right now. Surprisingly, few details have really emerged from those discussions about what a final agreement might actually look like. But presumably, as we anticipate in our Canadian baseline forecast, we get some deal. The tariffs are not all going away. Some of the tariffs are going to remain. The US administration’s been pretty clear about that. But as long as they’re reduced, and as long as policy isn’t constantly changing, then businesses can get back to planning, and hiring picks back up, investment starts to pick back up.

Our baseline forecast is that the Canadian economy really just muddles through the first half of the year. Then we start to see some green shoots emerge in the later half of 2026. A big part of that forecast is also assuming that the US, Iran conflict starts to quiet down. Maybe not an official ceasefire, but at least trade through the Strait of Hormuz mostly normalizes, and there isn’t some significant long term damage to global supply chains or global energy markets. So maybe you want to call that optimistic, that both of these key risks, we’re saying end of 2026, we think they’re headed in a better direction. But if you’re on board with that, then what our models and our analysis are expecting is that growth will start to reaccelerate and the economy will start to regain momentum towards the end of 2026.

Adam Scalena: And what drives that momentum in your mind?

Brendan LaCerda: Part of it is that some of the tariffs do come off. Likely, particularly around the auto industry and the metals, that they bring those tariff rates down, and that helps to kickstart exports again. The other key factor is, Canada, open economy, highly dependent on foreign trade, has been attempting this pivot away from the United States, trying to find new export markets. We see some success. We can see that exports to the non-US globe are increasing. It just hasn’t been enough yet.

Part of the problem there is, you may argue, oh, these high oil prices are good for Canada, or at the very least, it offsets. Good for some parts, bad for other parts of Canada. But for the globe at large, this oil price shock is bad news and puts a serious dent in demand. I think oil is about 30 percent of Canadian exports. The other 70 percent of Canadian exports are under a lot of pressure right now because global demand is weak. So if energy prices come down, global growth starts to pick back up again, you’d expect demand for those other Canadian exports to also pick back up.

Adam Scalena: Brendan, you’ve been watching Canada for quite some time and studying the economy here. Can you talk about how Canada’s economy has changed over the past few years? And the other question kind of tied to that is, is it mostly an uncertainty story, or is there more to the picture about the Canadian economy? We often talk about policy changes and political leadership and all that sort of thing. Is there more to the story there?

Brendan LaCerda: I think there is, because I’ve been getting a lot of questions recently about, are high oil prices a net positive or a net negative for Canada? That seems to be one of the key questions at the moment. There’s this general conception, well, Canada is this big oil exporter, this has to be good for Canada. I think that assessment is probably more accurate or representative of what the Canadian economy looked like 20 years ago, maybe 30 years ago. Much more focused on goods production, much more focused on commodity exports.

But if we think about where so much of the economic growth has taken place in Canada in the last 20 years, it’s the boom towns like Toronto, Vancouver, a couple of other places too. And that economy is not oriented around natural resource extraction. It’s a modern service economy. Tech, software, increasingly now AI and other cloud computing. The Canadian economy has been shifting in that direction. So I’ve been trying to push the argument that on net, these high oil prices are probably bad for Canada, a net negative, whereas 30 years ago, it probably would have been a net positive.

Matt Scalena: Can we talk a little bit about how the different regions of Canada are doing? I don’t know how granular your modeling gets, but you mentioned the auto sector, which is primarily in Ontario, you mentioned high oil prices, which presumably benefits Alberta more than the gas prices in Vancouver. Can we talk about how different regions are doing right now? The strongest areas, the weaker areas, and when you talk about green shoots at the end of 2026, is that across the board, or are we going to see certain areas really emerge over others?

Brendan LaCerda: There’s probably a good opportunity to insert my shameless plug, which is we produce forecasts and alternative scenario forecasts for all 10 provinces and 32, 33 metro areas in Canada. So one of those insights we try to offer is to take that global macro picture and bring it down to the metro level and say, what does it mean specifically for different metro economies?

No surprise on the industrial diversity across Canada. Obviously, the big energy producing regions are going to be the beneficiaries here. So that means Alberta, also some North Atlantic oil off of Newfoundland, New Brunswick, things up there. There’s some offshore oil up there. But by and large, the big benefit here is to Alberta.

There’s one caveat on that. I wrote an article about this last week, which is that Canada seems to have a bit of a pipeline capacity problem. Think about the politics. Going back in the Trudeau administration when the Keystone XL pipeline was killed, there’s been a lot of opposition to running an east, west pipeline through British Columbia. Apart from a few exceptions, there hasn’t been significant investment in new pipeline capacity in Canada in a few decades. So Canadian pipelines are running at 90 percent plus capacity. The problem becomes, now prices shoot up, and as an oil producer your goal is to just try to get as many barrels to market as you can. That’s hard for Canadian producers right now. Rail capacity is also pretty tight. Pipeline capacity is tight. What it means is that this spike in oil prices is likely just to generate a windfall, temporary profit for Alberta.

The question of, could this lead to new investment, new jobs? Could it really change the long run trajectory on Alberta’s oil industry? I’m not so sure. Are oil producers going to invest in new wells and new pipelines just because the oil price is jacked up right now? They would get burned if suddenly a ceasefire, oil prices crash down, and then those investments don’t make sense anymore. One of the problems is that the cost of extracting a barrel in Alberta is much higher than many other key sources of oil elsewhere in the world. So typically, new investment in Alberta only makes sense when oil prices are really, really high, and they need to be high for a sustained period of time.

Depending on how this US, Iran conflict evolves, if this really goes on for a while, I think you could start to see a lot of countries look to Canada as a more reliable source of oil, in which case you would get a much bigger economic benefit coming into Alberta, new jobs, new investment, all that stuff. But I don’t think that’s likely to happen. So in terms of what this means for the different regions of Canada, for Alberta, it’s a big temporary windfall. For the rest of Canadians, they’re just feeling the pain at the pump, paying extra for gasoline.

Adam Scalena: In your mind, Brendan, is there any low hanging fruit that Canada can capitalize on to get the economy in a better spot? You suggested earlier that creating new trade relationships seems to be something that might be a green shoot in the future. Is that the way forward in your mind?

Brendan LaCerda: It’s not my proposal, it’s one that’s been discussed widely. The amount of interprovincial trade. I’m a professional economist, and even I wasn’t fully aware of all the different regulatory frameworks across provinces and how difficult it makes it for businesses to operate across the entire country. You just don’t see regulations like that in the United States. That’s a consequence of, in the US Constitution, there’s this thing called the Commerce Clause, and it basically says the federal government controls trade between states. States can’t make rules that infringe on other states. Because it’s controlled at the federal level, you get a much more centralized, uniform set of rules, and that makes it so much easier for businesses to operate. So I think it makes a lot more sense for Canadian provinces to ease their own regulation and allow for a more unified federal framework.

Matt Scalena: We’ve talked about the base case, and actually the base case sounds all right to me. We’re on the cusp of coming out of this. I feel like Vancouver real estate probably feels like we’ve definitely been in a recession, at least in the real estate business, and it’s been deeper and longer than probably the rest of Canada’s felt it. But that’s good news. Can we talk about some of the other potential directions we go? Maybe a more negative picture, and then maybe a more positive picture, and how Moody’s grades the potential for different outcomes.

Brendan LaCerda: Yeah, as I said at the top, we do a lot of alternative macroeconomic scenario forecasting that comes in a lot of different forms. Some of the scenarios we produce, we assign probabilities to those. Some scenarios we produce are just like a what if this happens. It’s just too hard to assign a probability to it.

If we think about risks at the moment, again, it goes back to the US, Iran conflict. The what if downside scenario, you have to start to imagine, what if we just get a prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and no oil moves through that? We can do something like quick back of the envelope calculations. About 20 percent of the world’s oil goes through the Strait of Hormuz. If that gets completely shut down, you have to ask yourself, well, how much would prices have to increase so that the quantity of oil people want to buy goes down by 20 percent?

The problem is that oil demand, oil consumption is not very sensitive to prices. How high would gas prices have to go before you change your driving and daily commuting habits, or cancel a planned road trip or vacation?

Matt Scalena: Right.

Brendan LaCerda: You really gotta jack up oil prices to get people to start cutting back. That’s what we call elasticities in economics, these sensitivities. If you look at what the literature and research says, the increase in price would have to be about five times the change in quantity. Which means if you lose 20 percent of the world’s oil, the price of oil would probably have to increase by 100 percent in order to get you back to an equilibrium. We were starting at, let’s say, US 60 before the conflict started. So the new equilibrium would be somewhere around 120 US a barrel.

That generates a significant inflation shock. And how does the central bank react in that case? I don’t think the Bank of Canada hikes rates. We put together a downside scenario where we have the conflict lasting longer, oil prices go higher. Even in that scenario, I don’t think the Bank of Canada raises interest rates. They allow the temporary increase in inflation, because the labor market is relatively weak at the moment, because the economy is relatively fragile because of tariffs and the other things going on. In that scenario, yeah, we get a mild recession. So nothing like COVID or the global financial crisis or anything on that scale. It’s kind of dot com bubble bursting kind of mild recession. So that’s our most likely downside scenario.

Part of that scenario also usually involves a steep drop in equity prices. It seems like equity prices are quite elevated at the moment relative to fundamentals. So there is an increased risk of a stock market correction at the moment. I think that’s why when the conflict kicked up, you saw that rapid pullback in equity prices, because valuations are pretty lofty right now. There’s a lot of downside risk in stock prices. So that rounds out the pessimistic scenario.

On the upside, anytime we think about upside scenarios, part of it would clearly involve a rapid de-escalation of geopolitical risk. But probably the biggest potential upside driver right now is productivity gains from artificial intelligence, and the investment and the return on that. We are starting to see that in some of the data. It’s very preliminary. We were working on some AI scenarios. There are, of course, darker AI scenarios. But I personally tend to be more of a tech optimist when it comes to these things, and we have scenarios that reflect that. I think that’s the easiest way you get to an upside scenario. Geopolitical risks come down, and you get something that helps boost productivity growth, particularly in Canada, where productivity growth has been a significant issue for many years, over a decade, and been a big part of the conversation. Optimistic that artificial intelligence and these new kind of investments could help rekindle productivity growth in Canada.

Matt Scalena: Before we get to that, you mentioned that you don’t think the Bank of Canada raises rates this year. One thing that we’ve been noticing, and this is literally on the ground, is that the five year fixed rates and the three year fixed rates have increased over the last couple months. There’s been some bond volatility, I guess. How does this all link to real estate, just to get down to it. This is a real estate podcast. So if rates stay, the base case strikes me as a good news story, fairly boring kind of charts with what local economists are talking about with the real estate market, that sales volume should increase gradually over 2026. We should churn through some of our inventory and get back to a healthier market. What’s your take on the Canadian real estate environment?

Brendan LaCerda: Going back to what you said about rates, I think the changes you’re seeing largely reflect that investors had penciled in a couple US Fed cuts for 2026, thinking, okay, inflation is cooling down in the United States. It’s been more elevated than it has been in Canada because of the tariffs. Inflation in Canada, it’s going to go up, but it did get under 2 percent briefly. It’s been more elevated in the United States. So the expectation was, we’re going to get two, three rate cuts in 2026. Those are coming off because of what’s happening with energy prices and inflation.

It’s not just domestic interest rates in Canada that can affect the Canadian mortgage rate. It depends on the overall global credit conditions. How tight are global credit markets? Because Canadian banks don’t just raise capital in Canada, they raise capital from all over the world. The United States is sort of that global benchmark. So financial conditions are tighter than expected. Banks are changing their forecast for 2026, and that’s why you saw those rates perk back up.

Going forward though, I said I don’t expect the Bank of Canada to raise rates, but they’re certainly not going to cut rates in this environment. So the trouble is, if you’re in the real estate market, you shouldn’t anticipate any interest rate relief coming down the road. Frankly, where mortgage rates are right now, we think it’s pretty close to their long run average, their long run equilibrium. So people expecting, we’re going to go back to the glory days of, I can get a mortgage for like 2 percent, I don’t see that realistically, unless there’s some horrible recession where the Bank of Canada just starts slashing rates. That’s the only way we get back to a 2 percent mortgage again.

So then the other part you ask yourself is, the other big driver of housing is going to be the labor market. There, one piece of caution I’ve been putting out recently is that because of the changes in immigration policy, that is causing the Canadian labor force to shrink, which is skewing some of the labor market statistics. In particular, it actually ends up making unemployment look lower than it actually is. Even though unemployment’s been pretty flat recently, I think that probably overstates the health of the labor market.

That being said, going back to the baseline forecast I talked about before, while Canada is stuck in this soft patch, we expect growth to start to accelerate at the end of the year. That means hiring comes back. That means income growth, wage growth starts to pick up. And that will help kickstart or inject some fresh life back into the housing market. Certainly it’s been a rough stretch for housing in Canada the last few years. But even with all the ups and the downs in house prices, one of the things I’ve really been struck by is how strong new construction has actually remained.

You think about some of the price drops, you think about, is this spooking builders? Are they going to pull back on the number of new intentions, permitting, number of new homes they’re building? Not really. I was looking at the Vancouver stats this morning. Number of units under construction, still near all time record high. Pace of new housing starts, slowed down a little, but it’s still pretty brisk. Permitting is still pretty strong.

Maybe the final point I’ll make here is, when you do hear people complain about affordability in the housing market, which is a definite issue, that also means a person who’s complaining about affordability is a person who wants to buy a house. So the demand is out there if you can get that affordability a little back into a better place. If you look at our house price forecast for Canada, we have house prices coming down a little bit more as we get through 2026. But income growth keeps going. Interest rates mostly stay flat. That improves affordability. That’s going to bring some new demand back into the market.

Adam Scalena: Just to piggyback on those comments, we’re down roughly, the stats will tell you approximately 7 percent or so in this market, but I think it’s probably more like just rounded out at around 10 percent plus or minus a few points on either side, depending on the submarket. In your mind then, is Vancouver a buy right now for people? Or are you anticipating that this time next year we’ll be in a better position then?

Brendan LaCerda: Given Vancouver is the most expensive real estate market in Canada, it’s hard to deem it a buy, because does every other market in Canada have to be a buy too? Certainly there are amenities, quality of life. I visited Vancouver a couple of times, love the city. I understand why people are willing to pay a premium to live there. I don’t know if I can characterize it as a buy opportunity.

Considering, if you look at the shape of our scenarios for the Vancouver market, there’s a small upside and a big downside, I would say. Ask yourself, realistically, even in your most optimistic scenario for the Vancouver real estate market, what type of appreciation would you think you could get over the next few years? Versus, paint a dark scenario, how big could those price declines be? If you think about those scenarios around the baseline forecast, there’s a lot of downside skew in the Vancouver market because of that affordability problem, because valuations are so high.

Adam Scalena: Well, to that point, a common conversation right now about Vancouver real estate is that we’re kind of moving more to a typical Canadian city, where we might do 2 to 4 percent per year, kind of click along potentially. But the big runs of 20 percent annually are basically gone for the foreseeable future. Do you think that’s an inaccurate portrayal?

Brendan LaCerda: I think it would probably be good for the Vancouver real estate market to catch its breath a little bit. It wasn’t just the big price run up in 2020, around 2021. We also had a big run up in prices around 2016, 2017. So we really had back to back booms in the Vancouver real estate market. So I guess that gets to my upside, downside scenario. Can you really expect a third boom in a row now? That just seems unrealistic.

It’s likely to be the case that if you’re judging the real estate market purely in terms of annual appreciation, I think you’d expect Vancouver to be a laggard versus the national average and some other areas, where areas that are more affordable are going to see more in migration. I think that’s one of the fundamental problems for Vancouver. The worse that affordability gets, it starts acting against migration. Fewer and fewer people are going to decide, I can realistically afford to move and live in the city.

Matt Scalena: I wanted to go back to the comments about efficiency and AI and being a tech optimist. I hear a lot about the K shaped economy, and presumably AI doesn’t do anything to bridge the divide between the haves and the have nots, really. How is Moody’s thinking about AI that way in terms of their forecasting, in terms of potential job loss, in terms of maybe the GDP numbers looking great, but on the ground, it being kind of less of an economy that’s working for everyone?

Brendan LaCerda: Yeah, if you make some different assumptions, you can definitely get at some different end scenarios for artificial intelligence. Specifically the one you’re talking about, this K shaped forecast, where for viewers that aren’t familiar, that would be all the benefit goes to the high income folks, low income folks lose their jobs. It’s a two part recovery. Rich folks do well, poor folks bottom line.

I think the big question there is, who captures the profits from AI? Which is to say, all these big companies right now, Anthropic, whatever, are they going to, if you think about all these, they’re building all these new AI models. These companies are in this rat race with each other, constantly trying to outdo each other with better and better models. On some level, these AI models are becoming tools, they’re becoming commodified. Eventually there could be so many free AI models, AI agents out there, that the companies producing these have struggled to charge money for them.

The perfect example I’ll use, if we go back to the dot com boom and the IT revolution, there was a company called Global Crossing. What they did was they laid the undersea cables that were the backbone, the infrastructure of the entire internet. Everyone was thinking, Global Crossing, this is the company that controls, they’re building the infrastructure of the internet. This is going to be like the most valuable company on the face of the earth. Turns out no. I think they eventually went out of business or bankrupt or something. The reason is that eventually so many companies got in the game, laid so much cable, that there’s just a glut of bandwidth capacity, undersea internet cable. So they couldn’t charge people much money to use it.

In the same sense, if AI companies are going to capture the profits of AI in a K shape, so all the profits go to the AI overlords and everyone else is left with nothing, that scenario depends on the AI companies being able to protect their intellectual property. What I’m arguing in some sense is, couldn’t someone come along and rip them off, copy their product, or make a cheap imitation of their product that works almost as well for 90 percent of people? So there’s all this undercutting that can go on. In that case, to the extent that AI makes us more productive, more efficient, the profits from that would accrue to the companies that are using AI to build tools.

To use another example, going back to the dot com boom in the internet, who are the most profitable companies to emerge from that dot com boom? It’s Facebook, Google, Microsoft, a host of others. They didn’t make the internet. They just made products that service the internet, or help you use the internet. Social media, Facebook is a very good example, where this company didn’t invent the internet, but they created a product that uses the internet, and they’re the ones who are able to generate profit from that, less so than the people that own the cables and the switchboards and the infrastructure of the internet.

Matt Scalena: That makes sense. It’s those who will be able to use the tools to benefit.

Brendan LaCerda: That’s my key query. To summarize things, the question is, who’s going to profit from AI? Is it the companies building the AI tools right now, or is it going to be companies that are going to take those tools and build something else with it? I think that more spreads out the profits and the wealth.

Matt Scalena: That’s a really useful framing of it. One follow up question to that though is, thinking of the average Canadian making 80 grand a year or whatever, if those companies can use those tools to have 100 employees as opposed to 1,000 employees, how does that work? I guess, is Moody’s thinking about that? That’s yet to be seen, but presumably over time, fewer and fewer people are needed to run these companies.

Brendan LaCerda: That’s an interesting question, because then this raises the point, does AI complement labor, or is it a substitute for labor? You’re making the argument that there’s a risk here that AI is going to substitute, it’s going to replace labor. But on the other hand, employees can use these tools to make themselves more productive.

I was talking to a colleague, and one interesting example he pointed out was, we already have in the pizza industry, fully automated, sort of full automation. There are robots out there, you can press a button, and they’ll cook a pizza for you. Is that what we see, though, in practice, if you go around to different restaurants and things like that? To what extent have they actually automated their pizza ovens and other things of other sorts? Even though the technical ability might exist, it’s not a foregone conclusion that it’s just going to completely replace those workers. And how much adoption, or how deep is the adoption?

On the other hand, automation costs money. It’s not like you get rid of the worker and you just get to keep the money. You would have to replace that worker with a machine running on some software. There’s going to be maintenance costs associated with that. So there are costs on the other side of things. And then what if new technology comes along and you want to update your machine? How complicated is that? So it’s not exactly clear that AI is going to be a substitute for labor.

The other point I always like to make is, I think it’s a lot easier to imagine which jobs might go away versus which jobs are going to get created. The story I always use, my father worked for a Canadian printing and publishing company. So you can imagine, dot com boom comes along, demand for printed materials, books, magazines, newspapers, all that sort of stuff collapses. As sad as it was, my father ended up losing his job. Would the alternative be better, where we never got computers and the internet, and we’re all still reading books, magazines, and newspapers? As much as it was hard for my family, I don’t think I could say, we have to stop progress, we can’t advance technology anymore because some people are going to lose their jobs because we came out with a new technology.

Certainly the government needs a mindset of, for those people who lose their jobs, how can we re-skill them? How can we give them new skills to compete in the global labor market? You have to think about re-skilling for those people who do lose their jobs. But on the other hand, go back 20 years ago. Get in a time machine, go back 20 years ago. Ask most people, what’s a podcaster? I don’t know. That job didn’t even exist 20 years ago. So that’s my point. AI is going to create new jobs, and since we’re not there yet, it’s just hard to imagine what those jobs are even going to be.

Matt Scalena: Fair enough. Well, maybe we’ll leave it there, Brendan. We do have this segment that you may remember called the Five Wire. Five light hearted questions to finish the show. Do you have time to stick around for that?

Brendan LaCerda: Absolutely. Couldn’t miss it.

Matt Scalena: All right. Maybe I’ll start. The first question always: one book you’ve read recently, on the page turner side, whether it was actually a hard copy or not, that you’d recommend.

Brendan LaCerda: Speaking of AI, with the whole kickoff of AI, I actually got into, I wanted to go back in time and read some sci-fi novels from the 1940s, 50s, where rocketry and space exploration are just getting off the ground. Because it’s very interesting to see how they speculate about what the future of space is going to look like, and it’s very much like we’re speculating right now. So the book I’m going to recommend is called Rendezvous with Rama. It’s by Arthur C. Clarke. Famous sci-fi novel. Basically, it’s a very interesting mystery. The people on Earth, they start to see a spacecraft. It’s not making any communication. It’s just heading towards Earth. And they’re going to send a crew to go see what’s going on.

Particularly because you get that going back in time and looking forward, I think it’s very fascinating, what did people in the past speculate about what the future was going to look like.

Matt Scalena: Right, and how right or wrong they got it. That’s great.

Brendan LaCerda: Yeah, it’s like, you’re shocked, and you’re like, oh my God, they perfectly predicted this. Then other things, you’re like, that was a product of the times.

Adam Scalena: Question number two, in the last few years, what new belief, behavior, or habit has most improved your life?

Brendan LaCerda: The golf driving range. I’m not sure if either of you are golfers, but I was a big golfer when I was a kid. Then with my job, kids, I stopped playing. But now I’m looking for more reasons to get out of the house. One thing I’ve really found is nice, there’s a driving range five, 10 minutes down the road from me. On my lunch break, I drive over, grab a bucket of balls, and just crank away. It’s a little meditative, like a little meditation. It’s quiet. You’re not talking to anybody. You just sit there, and it gives you a distraction. You’re outside. That’s always a good thing too. So if anyone’s looking for a little mental health break, I’d recommend, go down to the driving range, hit a few balls.

Matt Scalena: That is a great one. What have you been binge watching lately, or favorite movie, recent favorite movie, I guess?

Brendan LaCerda: Favorite movie? I don’t know, it’s always like Netflix crud. What was the last one? The Night Agent. But I don’t even know if I would recommend it. It’s a spy, one of those spy thrillers. I love those spy thriller kind of shows. My bottom line, any show with an undercover agent, secret spy, going behind enemy lines, that’s always a winner for me. So Night Agent, I think is one of those shows on Netflix right now. Any of the Jack Ryan movies, or anything like that. I’m always a sucker for those.

Matt Scalena: It is true, though, what you say. The golden age of television is over, I think. It seems like even the stuff that’s celebrated right now is not great. You guys might disagree with me, but I had this thought last night. I was sitting on the couch, and I literally went back and started watching The Sopranos again from episode one, because I was like, this is just better TV. It’s better TV than anything out there. More interesting. Anyway, food for thought. Discuss. No, just joking. Moving on.

Adam Scalena: All right, question number four, Brendan. Favorite band or music?

Brendan LaCerda: I don’t know, I’ve been looking for something new. Sometimes I feel like I’m listening to the same songs over and over again. Recently I picked up a little side job, teaching at a local university, just because I work remote. It kind of felt nice to get out of the house, interact with some young kids. I don’t know why, but I started listening to the country music station as I drive to work now. I am not a country music fan. I’ve never been. I grew up in Boston, Massachusetts, the heart of Yankee America. There was no country music station in Boston when I was growing up. I don’t know what it is. The weather’s getting warm now. I want to put down my window. Got a happy. I don’t even know any of the names of the songs, to be frank. It’s country music radio. That’s my recommendation. Just throw on country music radio. It’s a change of pace.

Adam Scalena: I feel like you’re preaching to the choir here.

Matt Scalena: Right on. And last but not least, something you have purchased for under 1,500 US dollars that has had a positive impact on your life in the last couple of years.

Brendan LaCerda: I think you may have asked me this question before, and I’m not sure what answer I gave. I do have one recommendation. I think it was a year or two ago, I bought a 4K HD projector, and I built a quasi cinema room in my basement. I have a 100 inch projector screen. It’s got a little button up there, so you can lower it up and down. You have to put it in the basement, because it has to be completely dark in the room or it doesn’t work well. That was a few years ago. I bet it would be just about $1,500 US. So we’re pushing the limit of the budget here. But these HD projectors are really cool. We had some neighbors over the other day, and you can bring it outside and shoot it at the side of your house, to put up a basketball or football game or whatever people want to watch. I can’t believe how much I actually love this thing, and how much use I actually get out of it. So if you’re a bit of a home theater junkie, if you like that kind of stuff, get a projector.

Adam Scalena: I’ve got a neighbor who’s been encouraging me to get one of those for like three years now, and I think it’s around $2,700 Canadian or something, but he waxes poetic about it. He absolutely loves it though. I might have to do it at some point here. But that’s great.

Matt Scalena: Brendan, we know the website, but how can people that are interested in finding out more about what you guys are putting out in regards to Canada, but also the world, find out more about what’s going on over at Moody’s, and what you specifically are up to?

Brendan LaCerda: Yeah, it’s real easy. You can go to economy.com. That was actually our original name. Economy.com will bring you to us. Moody’s.com will also work, of course. Check out our social media and whatnot. We’re always posting articles and putting out different reports.

Adam Scalena: That was great. Hey, thanks again, Brendan. Tons of takeaways from that conversation. We look forward to having you back in the future and seeing how all of this unfolds.

Brendan LaCerda: All right, well, one year from today, we’ll check back in.

Matt Scalena: Right on. Okay, thanks again.

Brendan LaCerda: All right, great seeing you guys.